Create Desire and Tension: The Dopamine Secret to Grabbing (and Keeping) Attention
Anyone who’s tried to keep a group’s attention for more than five minutes knows: people drift unless you grab them with both anticipation and a sense of urgency. Neuroscience now explains why—it’s all about balancing two chemicals in the brain: dopamine (the promise of reward and novelty) and norepinephrine (the signal for tension and alertness).
Imagine you’re pitching a new school club activity. You spark excitement with a secret guest speaker (novelty) and mention the event will only happen if enough students sign up before Friday (tension). Some are drawn in by the prize, others by the risk of missing out, but together, everyone is curious and alert. This combination creates what psychologists call 'hot cognition'—attention that’s emotionally charged and focused.
If you only offer novelty (the cool guest speaker), students might get excited but feel no need to act. If you introduce only tension (the registration deadline), you risk triggering anxiety or resistance. But when you push them to act ('maybe this isn’t for everyone') and then pull them back in by revealing more rewards ('but together we could make something amazing'), you maintain attention for just long enough to get commitment.
Much like a great movie or suspenseful game, the interplay of desire and tension creates a loop that holds people in place. Miss one side, and you lose them. Combine both, and you command their focus.
Take a moment before your next presentation or group activity to find something genuinely novel or unexpected to introduce—then let your audience know there are real stakes or a clear deadline. Alternate between pushing people to consider if they're the right fit, and then pulling them back by describing what’s possible if they step up. Practice blending surprise and a bit of pressure, and notice how much longer and more deeply people pay attention. Give it a try with even a small group, and see how the energy changes.
What You'll Achieve
Feel more powerful in capturing attention and sparking real interest; reliably maintain engagement in presentations, meetings, or lessons by creating a balanced flow of excitement and urgency.
Balance Novelty with Real Stakes in Every Pitch
Offer a fresh, unexpected reward or novelty.
Surprise your audience with a new idea, demo, or insight—something that’s both desirable and different from expectations, creating a burst of curiosity.
Introduce genuine tension or a ticking clock.
Show that something important could be lost or gained, such as an opportunity, a deadline, or a decision with real consequences.
Push, then pull: create a tension loop.
Challenge your audience's fit or readiness, then reassure them of what's possible if things go right. Alternate between pushing them away and pulling them in.
Reflection Questions
- What is something truly novel you can offer your audience?
- How can you introduce real, meaningful stakes without resorting to manipulation?
- When have you experienced strong desire and tension as a listener—what made it work?
- Which part of this balance comes more naturally to you: surprise or challenge?
Personalization Tips
- At a club meeting, reveal an exciting new event—then explain it’ll only happen if members step up by next week.
- Pitch a new business idea by first highlighting what's at stake if action isn’t taken soon.
- As a teacher, introduce a game with a surprise twist, then create a competition to maintain engagement.
Pitch Anything: An Innovative Method for Presenting, Persuading, and Winning the Deal
Ready to Take Action?
Get the Mentorist app and turn insights like these into daily habits.