Stop chasing compliments and start uncovering trustworthy commitments
You know the feeling—you pitch your idea and the other person’s face lights up. They tell you it's brilliant, maybe the best thing they've heard all week. Your heart does a little leap. Maybe this is finally 'the one,' the genius move that will set everything in motion. But then, as the weeks pass, nobody replies to your emails, and the initial excitement fizzles into silence. Looking back, you realize: nobody actually committed to anything. They were just being nice.
This kind of feedback is easy to chase, especially if you’re hungry for validation or working on something that matters deeply to you. Our brains get hooked on compliments—they’re rewarding, and they mask the harder work of learning what’s true. But when you shift your focus, you notice who’s actually taking the next step. The person who introduces you to someone else. The friend who test-drives your prototype. The colleague who schedules a time to really work through your draft.
It feels different when someone puts something on the line. You taste the effort in their actions, whether it’s time, a favor, or a willingness to troubleshoot a messy first version. Sure, rejections sting. But real commitments—even a small one, like a friend sharing your beta app with their parent—are far better signals than a dozen warm 'likes.'
Psychology calls this seeking 'commitment signals'—looking for behaviors that show real investment. It's not just startup wisdom; it applies whenever you need to know what people will actually do, not just say. It may feel less thrilling at first, but it’s the surest way to build solutions that people willingly embrace.
Whenever you feel the warm glow of a compliment, pause for a second and let it settle without getting carried away. Then, nudge the conversation toward the facts: invite the person to walk you through a real example or offer a preview of their day. If things seem promising, make a gentle ask for something real—whether it’s trying out your solution, making an introduction, or committing time. If they hesitate, that tells you far more than enthusiasm ever could. Let these small steps guide you, turning flattery into real feedback that powers your next move.
What You'll Achieve
You’ll grow more comfortable with rejection, become skilled at telling authentic feedback from surface-level support, and cultivate discipline in advancing only on reliable information. Externally, you’ll build stronger partnerships, speed up learning loops, and avoid wasting effort on initiatives that have buzz but no backbone.
Turn Flattery Into Evidence You Can Test
Politely deflect praise and steer toward facts.
When someone says, 'That sounds great' or compliments your idea, thank them briefly, then redirect: 'Can you walk me through how you handle this problem right now?'
Ask for a concrete next step.
Instead of accepting vague interest, ask for a measurable action—like trying a prototype, introducing you to a colleague, or giving feedback on an actual workflow.
Evaluate commitment based on what they give up.
True signals of interest involve giving up time, social capital, or money. If someone only offers encouragement, recognize it as support, not evidence.
Reflection Questions
- How do I usually react to compliments about my ideas?
- What’s the smallest real commitment I could ask for today?
- How can I track actual advances versus just positive feedback?
Personalization Tips
- When showing a new student club idea, don’t settle for 'cool!'—ask if they’ll help organize the next meeting.
- If you get supportive words at a family dinner, see if someone will actually share your survey with a friend.
- During a team brainstorm, shift from 'That’s awesome!' to 'Would you be willing to test-run this next week?'
The Mom Test: How to talk to customers & learn if your business is a good idea when everyone is lying to you
Ready to Take Action?
Get the Mentorist app and turn insights like these into daily habits.