Pick Your Market Wisely: When Even Great Offers Fail
A skilled software entrepreneur spent years pitching small newspapers on digital ad solutions, certain his offer was unbeatable. The price was fair, the value clear, and he poured effort into sales, but demand shrank each year. Frustrated, he doubled down, tweaking features and guarantees. Eventually, he realized the hard truth: his customers, the newspapers themselves, were dying out. He switched focus to an exploding demand in pandemic supplies and, using the same skills, sold millions. The lesson hit home—no offer, no matter how irresistible, can succeed in a market on the way out.
Smart business builders first hunt for 'starving crowds'—those who already want, even need, a solution now, not those who might someday care. Success comes when problems are acute, people can pay, and you can actually find and talk to them. Niche hopping may feel appealing, but sticking with a viable, if challenging, audience is almost always better than starting over. Scientific research on market selection and pattern recognition supports this: survival is likeliest not from innovation alone, but from serving urgent, unserved needs where demand exists.
Before you deepen your next big move, pause and rigorously check if people in your chosen field are truly hungry for what you solve—are they searching, buying, complaining, desperate? List your ideal customers' pains, make sure they can pay, and join their online hangouts or meetings. Once you're sure, stay the course and get to know every nuance of their struggle. You'll save years of frustration and focus your creative power where it counts.
What You'll Achieve
Achieve clarity and focus, reduce wasted effort, and find faster business growth by aligning your energy with obvious demand—not wishful thinking.
Find a Starving Crowd Instead of Trying to Create Hunger
Validate demand in your market before building your offer.
Look for clear signs of unsolved, urgent pain in growing or at least stable markets. Avoid industries in decline, regardless of your passion for them.
Assess purchasing power and ease of targeting.
Check that your chosen customers can afford your solution and can be found easily—via groups, mailing lists, online forums, or professional circles.
Commit to your niche once chosen.
Once you’ve picked a market with real demand, resist the urge to pivot at the first sign of struggle. Instead, double down until you truly understand their pain.
Reflection Questions
- Is my industry shrinking, stagnant, or growing—how can I tell?
- Who has bought something similar recently, and why?
- Does my target customer group actually gather anywhere I can reach them?
- If my first offers fail, will I learn and adapt or just jump to a new niche?
Personalization Tips
- Tech jobs: Focus resume services on mid-career professionals who need help now, not college students with no budget.
- Restaurants: Start with neighborhoods lacking your food style, not ones saturated with options.
- Fitness: Target new parents or retirees with proven need instead of fit college athletes.
$100M Offers: How To Make Offers So Good People Feel Stupid Saying No
Ready to Take Action?
Get the Mentorist app and turn insights like these into daily habits.