Why the fastest path to peak performance is designing teams as communities, not collections of individuals
Research on team productivity shows that groups designed as interconnected communities—not just skilled individuals—consistently outperform rivals, even when individual ‘stars’ are present. In Google’s 'Project Aristotle,' the highest-performing teams weren't packed with graduate degrees or solo geniuses. Instead, they had regular rituals highlighting group achievements, paired collaborations, and open conversations about tension points. The science is clear: communities nourish engagement, buffer burnout, and foster creativity by assuring each member their effort ties to a larger whole.
Historically, business often saw internal competition as the main motivator, assuming rivalry kept everyone sharp. But studies reveal the opposite: unaddressed tensions, competition for credit, and 'status conflicts' erode trust and create waste. The trick is not to eliminate all conflict, but to purposely surface and resolve it through structured practices, pairing frustrated members for side projects, and refocusing praise on group wins.
Case after case, including large manufacturing studies and creative industries like video game design, confirm that community design—shared rituals, public recognition, and cross-silo pairings—transforms even aggressive, driven teams into bonded, resilient groups with lasting impact.
This week, make a point to publicly highlight someone who helped a colleague or sacrificed for the team, not just the star performer. Find a small project or routine where you can intentionally pair two people who haven’t worked closely before and encourage them to communicate regularly. When you sense growing tension or competition, bring it into a group conversation, naming your shared goal as the highest priority. Building a community isn’t about eliminating ego, but binding it to a purpose everyone can own.
What You'll Achieve
You’ll create an environment where people are motivated by shared wins, support each other through difficulties, and develop deep relationships that multiply fivefold returns in productivity and well-being.
Shape Your Team as a Community
Draw attention to the team’s shared purpose and collective wins.
Regularly highlight contributions that benefit the group, not just individual achievements. Celebrate people who help each other or make sacrifices for team success.
Pair teammates intentionally and create partnership projects.
Rotate groupings or assign joint responsibilities, even for small tasks, to encourage relationship-building and mutual reliance.
Spot and address collective tension early.
When “status conflicts” or silos appear, bring them to the surface. Discuss tensions openly in a safe environment, naming the team above egos.
Reflection Questions
- Do I recognize group contributions as much as individual ones?
- How can I mix up team pairings to build more trust and understanding?
- What recurring tension or rivalry needs to be named and resolved?
Personalization Tips
- In a study group, two students from different backgrounds collaborate on a research assignment and share what they learned from each other.
- A startup co-founder rotates monthly one-on-ones among all team members to spot and solve potential misunderstandings.
Trillion Dollar Coach: The Leadership Playbook of Silicon Valley's Bill Campbell
Ready to Take Action?
Get the Mentorist app and turn insights like these into daily habits.