Why Five Customers Can Tell You More Than 1000 Survey Respondents—The Power of Small Data

Hard - Requires significant effort Recommended

Decades of usability research—from software to physical products—have consistently shown that you don't need massive surveys to improve your design; you need meaningful, close-up observation of a handful of real users. When a team at a tech company was preparing to launch a new service, they debated if customer testing would be worth it. Some argued for sending out online surveys to hundreds of people. Others proposed in-person interviews with just five carefully chosen individuals.

The latter group won out. During a day of one-on-one sessions, customer after customer encountered the same obstacle on a key screen. One struggled with an ambiguous button, another hesitated with a confusing prompt, and by the third interview, the solution was clear: the issue was obvious and fixable. The company made rapid improvements before launch, saving them untold embarrassment and frustration.

The core behavioral principle at work is diminishing returns—after five users, each new interview reveals fewer unique issues. The richest, most actionable data comes from personal observation, not sheer volume. Teams that believe in 'small data' waste fewer resources, iterate faster, and end up with better products.

Identify five people who genuinely represent your target user and get their honest, unfiltered feedback on your prototype. Watch closely; most major problems and highlights will emerge quickly and clearly. Take note, be ready to change things, and don’t fool yourself into thinking you need an avalanche of data. This kind of testing is faster, cheaper, and infinitely more revealing than any survey—so set up your first round of interviews this week. You’ll be amazed at how much you learn before you spend big.

What You'll Achieve

You’ll save immense time and money by making adjustments before launch—catching major problems early and building confidence in your solution. Internally, you’ll feel less uncertain and more empowered to overhaul what's not working.

Test With Five Real People Before You Scale

1

Recruit five target users matching your ideal customer.

Look for people who actually fit your audience—not experts or insiders. If you need a broader mix, adjust as you go along.

2

Have them interact with your prototype in a realistic setting.

Let each person attempt the main goal, narrate their thoughts, and express any frustrations or excitement as naturally as possible.

3

Observe and document clear patterns.

With as few as five people, genuine pain points and moments of delight will emerge repeatedly. Focus on these signals to decide what needs fixing or doubling down.

Reflection Questions

  • What have you learned from direct observation that surveys missed?
  • Who are your ‘perfect five’ users for the next test?
  • How do you handle feedback that contradicts your expectations?
  • What would it take to set up a test this week?

Personalization Tips

  • A teacher observes just five students using a new handout, instantly spotting two confusing sections.
  • A small business owner tests her checkout page on five actual customers, finding a sticking point everyone else missed.
  • A community organizer pilots a new flyer with five neighborhood volunteers before printing thousands.
Sprint: How to Solve Big Problems and Test New Ideas in Just Five Days
← Back to Book

Sprint: How to Solve Big Problems and Test New Ideas in Just Five Days

Jake Knapp
Insight 6 of 9

Ready to Take Action?

Get the Mentorist app and turn insights like these into daily habits.