Why Your True Self Often Gets Buried—And How To Reclaim It In A Hyperconnected World

Hard - Requires significant effort Recommended

Modern life teaches young people, especially girls, to present edited, filtered versions of themselves just to fit in or rack up likes. Social media, advertising, and even well-meaning adults often send mixed messages—be honest but don’t upset anyone, be strong but always be agreeable. Over time, it’s easy for the true self—the messy, creative, fiercely unique part that loves, learns, and fights for what matters—to get buried under endless performances and anxiety about how you appear to others.

But psychologists like Alice Miller and generations of adolescent therapists have shown that when girls abandon their authentic voices just to be accepted, they lose confidence, joy, and even their sense of direction. Miller calls this the split into a ‘false self’—the version we sharpen for the crowd—and the loss of the ‘true self’—the vast realm where our real needs, talents, and dreams live. This isn’t just about individual willpower; social forces, technology, and subtle cultural rules push everyone in this direction. Still, it is possible to notice the split happening in everyday moments and to gently reclaim what’s real and lasting.

Simple practices—like uninterrupted creative time, honest conversations, and reconnecting with childhood passions—give space for the true self to resurface. Small actions, repeated over time, can restore authenticity and build resilience against the pressures of performance and perfection. Honest self-reflection and the support of trusted allies are your best tools for staying whole in a world that profits from your uncertainty.

Think about the things you loved as a kid before you cared what others thought—drawing superheroes, inventing stories, exploring outside. This week, set aside a chunk of time to try one out again, without posting or asking for anyone’s opinion. Keep track of those moments when you feel yourself trying to perform just to fit in—jot them down, no judgment. Then make space to be alone with your interests, maybe reading, doodling, or playing music no one else hears. Finally, share one genuine passion with someone who supports you, whether that’s sending a song you wrote or telling your parent about a memory. The more you prioritize these quiet, authentic moments, the easier it is to remember and protect the real you beneath all the noise.

What You'll Achieve

Build greater self-acceptance and inner stability, reduce anxiety about others' opinions, and develop resilience to peer and cultural pressure, leading to stronger, longer-lasting confidence and happiness.

Reconnect With Your Authentic Interests—Not Just What’s Trending

1

Identify what genuinely excites you from childhood or pre-adolescence.

Set aside 10–20 quiet minutes and list activities, hobbies, or subjects that used to make you lose track of time before worries about popularity or perfection crept in.

2

Notice when you're acting just to fit in or get approval.

For a week, keep a brief log: jot down moments when you change your behavior, style, online persona, or answers mainly to avoid criticism or to win praise.

3

Schedule regular moments for solo reflection or creation.

Unplug for at least 30 minutes each week to read, write, draw, go for a walk, play music, or simply sit in nature—without sharing or scrolling. See which activities bring calm or joy.

4

Share one authentic passion with someone you trust.

Once you've identified something meaningful, talk about it or show it to a friend, parent, or mentor—not to impress, but to reconnect with your own enjoyment.

Reflection Questions

  • When do you feel most like yourself—unfiltered and at ease?
  • What activities or interests did you give up to fit in?
  • How does seeking approval affect your mood or choices?
  • Are there safe places or people where your true self feels welcomed?
  • What small step can you take to reconnect with an authentic interest this week?

Personalization Tips

  • A student who used to love painting plans one tech-free Saturday to experiment with watercolors at home, just for fun.
  • A parent joins their daughter for a nature walk, both leaving their phones behind, sharing stories of what they notice.
  • A teacher incorporates journaling time into class, encouraging students to reflect on what genuinely excites them beyond grades or social status.
Reviving Ophelia: Saving the Selves of Adolescent Girls
← Back to Book

Reviving Ophelia: Saving the Selves of Adolescent Girls

Mary Pipher
Insight 1 of 8

Ready to Take Action?

Get the Mentorist app and turn insights like these into daily habits.