Why Forcing Kids Backfires: Try Encouraging, Waiting, and Modeling Instead
Think about the last time you felt forced into an activity by someone else, even if well-meaning—maybe a meeting at work, a dinner you didn’t choose, or a project foisted on your Saturday. Did you feel excited, or simply trapped?
Children feel this double, especially when every order comes from a place of urgency or control. In many Indigenous families, orders are rare, and so is resistance. Instead, parents invite children: 'Come help,' or, 'Watch while I cook.' There’s no penalty for opting out, and no fuss if kids walk away. Over time, even the most stubborn or shy kids naturally join in, driven by curiosity or pride, not fear. The household feels less tense, less like a set of rules and more like a cooperative, peaceful community.
This approach aligns with self-determination theory: autonomy is a basic psychological need, and honoring it builds trust, motivation, and resilience. A mindful shift from control to respect transforms both everyday chores and long-term relationships.
Pause before you issue your next order or schedule. Instead, craft your invitations with warmth and purpose: 'Let’s do it together,' or, 'You can watch or help when you’re ready.' When you meet a 'no,' release it—carry on, and let your own calm presence do the teaching. Over time, notice how willingness grows, and how your home feels lighter, less like a battlefield. Challenge yourself to let go of pressure and model the behavior you hope to see, trusting that learning happens best in a spirit of true encouragement.
What You'll Achieve
Build stronger, less adversarial connections where children (and adults) find their own motivation to participate, leading to more genuine collaboration and less daily resistance.
Invite, Demonstrate, and Let Kids Refuse Without Fear
Replace orders with invitations to join.
Instead of commanding your child to do something, warmly ask them to join you or watch, making refusal an acceptable option.
Demonstrate tasks and let them observe or imitate.
Do the work yourself calmly and let the child see or copy at their own pace, without pressure or lecture.
Respect refusals and move on without drama.
If your child declines to help, don't negotiate or punish—simply carry on. Children are more likely to try on their own when they sense freedom and lack of coercion.
Reflection Questions
- How do I typically respond when my child says 'no'?
- What would it feel like to let someone refuse my request without taking it personally?
- Where can I shift from command to invitation in my routines?
Personalization Tips
- Friendships: Invite friends to join plans without guilt if they say no.
- Leadership: Demonstrate a new workflow and let team members try when ready, not on command.
- Partner: Suggest a walk rather than insisting on it; let your partner join when motivated.
Hunt, Gather, Parent: What Ancient Cultures Can Teach Us About the Lost Art of Raising Happy, Helpful Little Humans
Ready to Take Action?
Get the Mentorist app and turn insights like these into daily habits.