Why Resolving Every Disagreement Is Both Impossible and Overrated

Hard - Requires significant effort Recommended

Many people believe a good relationship means resolving every point of friction. The truth is nearly 70% of long-term partnership conflicts are perpetual; they're rooted in core personality, values, or life goals. Take the example of a couple who continually clash over spending time with in-laws—over the years, the details change, but the underlying tension remains.

In practice, couples who thrive don’t fix every disagreement. Instead, they find ways to live with persistent differences, often by using humor, expressing affection, and maintaining a sense of perspective. One morning, while rifling through a cluttered kitchen, a partner might roll their eyes and joke about their spouse’s 'creative organization,' both laughing as they clean up together. The conflict, while present, becomes a shared quirk instead of a battleground.

The most damaging relationships are those where unsolvable problems become gridlocked—partners dig in, become more extreme, and start to vilify each other. The couples who weather these unmovable issues best are the ones who talk about them openly, sidestep unnecessary escalation, and focus on what works rather than what's missing.

This approach is not just easy-going acceptance, but a recognition, supported by relationship science, that emotional gridlock over values is corrosive. Marital success is not about 'solving' every issue, but about handling perpetual differences with curiosity and compassion.

Take a quiet moment to jot down the fights or tensions that just keep returning year after year, and circle the ones you suspect will never fully disappear. Allow yourself to see these patterns with gentle honesty—the goal isn't to fix them, but to lower the temperature by accepting that some things are, simply, differences. Focus instead on talking about these topics with kindness, making room for laughs or shared routines, and letting go of the idea that you both need to be exactly alike to be happy together. Start with one ongoing issue today and change your response.

What You'll Achieve

Learn to accept and manage unsolvable problems with humor and perspective, reducing tension and emotional gridlock, while building trust and mutual respect.

Distinguish Perpetual Issues from Solvable Ones First

1

Identify recurring conflicts without solutions.

List topics or disagreements that repeatedly surface—such as differences in neatness, family involvement, or parenting style—that never seem to go away, no matter how many discussions you have.

2

Classify each issue as 'perpetual' or 'solvable.'

Reflect on the nature of each problem: perpetual issues are rooted in personality or core values and persist over time, whereas solvable problems are situation-specific and can be resolved with compromise.

3

Change expectations around unsolvable problems.

Accept that not every issue requires a solution. Instead, focus on healthy dialogue, humor, and mutual respect when addressing recurring differences.

Reflection Questions

  • Which recurring disagreements have you tried to 'solve' without success?
  • How could you approach these lasting issues with more humor or understanding?
  • Are there any ways you could honor each other's values without demanding change?

Personalization Tips

  • A couple repeatedly disagrees on housework routines, but rather than expecting a complete transformation, they agree on gentle reminders and established routines to reduce daily stress.
  • Siblings with clashing values about family traditions stop arguing over who is 'right' and instead learn to celebrate their differences, scheduling activities that honor what matters most to each.
The Seven Principles for Making Marriage Work: A Practical Guide from the Country's Foremost Relationship Expert
← Back to Book

The Seven Principles for Making Marriage Work: A Practical Guide from the Country's Foremost Relationship Expert

John M. Gottman
Insight 2 of 8

Ready to Take Action?

Get the Mentorist app and turn insights like these into daily habits.