Why trusting 'universal' rules leads to unnecessary stress and less effective decisions

Easy - Can start today Recommended

You’re sitting in the doctor’s office, clutching a brochure with a nervous thumb, the fluorescent lights humming above you. On the list: no caffeine, no sushi, absolutely no cold cuts. The rules feel endless, and with each one, your anxiety rises. But then you notice your best friend, who’s also expecting, sipping a post-dinner espresso with a gentle shrug, her mother mentioning how 'everyone ate cheese back in Sweden.' The contradiction leaves you baffled—and a little annoyed.

As the weeks go by, the rules pile up—one friend swears by a prenatal yoga ban, another says chocolate is off-limits. None of it seems to match your own needs, and it’s stressful trying to keep tabs. You start to ask, “What’s the reason for this?” But when you probe further, sometimes your doctor gives you a number, sometimes a vague ‘just to be safe.’ You poke around online and notice global recommendations differ wildly. Why? Who’s right?

Gradually, you’re emboldened to test the process yourself. You love coffee, so you dive into the data. Turns out, a modest amount is safe. You decide to keep your morning cup and immediately feel less deprived—sleep’s a bigger issue, anyway. Over time, your confidence grows, and you challenge other rules, one by one, tailoring each decision to your personal priorities and the actual risks.

This approach draws on the principles of decision science and behavioral economics, recognizing that effective choices combine reliable information with personal valuation. When you personalize instead of blindly following rules, anxiety drops, satisfaction rises, and you reclaim agency in your care.

Start with one guideline you have taken for granted—maybe it’s the rule against coffee or the warning about salads. Ask yourself what fear or risk the rule targets and see if you can find a concrete reason or scientific study behind it. Weigh how much that activity or habit matters in your daily life, considering your personal needs. Then, choose to either follow the rule as is, adapt it to fit your reality, or let it go entirely—whatever feels right and supported. Pay attention to how even a small act of tailoring rules to you can dramatically reduce stress and boost your sense of control. Try this approach with just one rule today, and see how your confidence grows.

What You'll Achieve

Achieve a calmer mindset by rejecting unnecessary stress from arbitrary rules, enjoy daily life more by adapting guidance to your needs, and foster a sense of control and satisfaction with your decisions.

Stop Following Rules Blindly—Personalize Every Pregnancy Decision

1

Identify an Existing Rule or Guideline You’ve Encountered.

Think about a pregnancy rule—no coffee, no deli meat, no exercise—recommended to you. Write it down or state it clearly.

2

Investigate the Reason Behind the Rule.

Ask, 'What is this supposed to achieve? What science or risk is mentioned?' Seek out at least one piece of evidence, even if it’s just your doctor’s rationale or a web search.

3

Compare the Rule to Your Personal Preferences and Situation.

Reflect on how much you value what the rule is limiting (e.g., daily coffee vs. occasional enjoyment), and whether the risk applies to you.

4

Make an Intentional, Informed Choice.

Decide whether to follow or adapt the rule, based on both the data and what matters most to you.

Reflection Questions

  • Which rule or restriction has caused you the most stress or confusion?
  • What’s stopping you from questioning it or adjusting it to fit your life?
  • How much would your daily comfort or happiness improve if you made this one change?
  • What evidence or reassurance do you need to feel confident in a different choice?

Personalization Tips

  • A student wants to keep running track during pregnancy but is told to stop; she checks the evidence and continues with modifications.
  • A parent is told to avoid all sushi but, after reviewing the true risks, chooses reputable sources and avoids only high-risk items.
  • Someone is told not to take allergy medication but finds the specific drug is actually safe and chooses to continue, improving sleep and comfort.
Expecting Better: Why the Conventional Pregnancy Wisdom is Wrong - and What You Really Need to Know
← Back to Book

Expecting Better: Why the Conventional Pregnancy Wisdom is Wrong - and What You Really Need to Know

Emily Oster
Insight 1 of 8

Ready to Take Action?

Get the Mentorist app and turn insights like these into daily habits.