Why Trusting Your First Judgement Can Miss the Bigger Picture
It’s common to let our first gut instinct set the tone for how we treat someone new. Maybe you meet a neighbor who lingers at the crosswalk and instantly assume he’s bad news, based only on superficial cues like his hair or clothes. But snap judgments often leave out important context. When you rush to categorize someone as a 'stalker,' you may miss subtle social signals—like the awkwardness of meeting in close quarters or the harmless reality of sharing the same building.
This pattern plays out everywhere: in the classroom, on sports teams, at work. Often, our brains are wired to spot threats and make calls quickly as a survival tool. But in safe environments, this impulse can cause unnecessary distance or missed opportunities for connection. Slowing down is uncomfortable because uncertainty activates our natural anxiety about the unknown, but it also creates space for more accurate, compassionate understanding.
Later, when you find out your neighbor had a perfectly good reason to be there (he lives next door), you feel embarrassed about your whole mental spiral. This self-awareness is crucial: it’s not about blaming yourself for the reaction, but about practicing curiosity before judgement. Cognitive science calls this 'system 1' (fast, automatic) versus 'system 2' (slow, reflective) thinking. When you move to system 2—even for a few moments—you give others, and yourself, the benefit of the doubt. This openness can transform anxiety into empathy, and strangers into friends.
Next time you meet someone new and feel yourself making a snap judgement, challenge that instinct by noticing your knee-jerk reaction and slowing down. Consciously gather more information, look for alternative explanations, and remember times your first impressions were off base. Giving yourself this extra beat to reflect can help you approach new relationships—and all the awkwardness they bring—with more curiosity and less anxiety. Try this experiment today with someone you don’t know well.
What You'll Achieve
You’ll cultivate more accurate perceptions of others, reduce unnecessary anxiety, and gain new openness to connection. Internally, this builds patience, confidence, and self-acceptance. Externally, you'll foster warmer interactions, fewer social misunderstandings, and more meaningful relationships.
Pause Before Judging Strangers’ Behavior
Notice your knee-jerk reactions.
When you meet someone new, pay attention to any immediate labels or assumptions you attach to them (e.g., 'creep,' 'unfriendly').
Gather more information.
Look for additional evidence before confirming your original assumption. For example, if someone seems unfriendly, check if they might be tired or distracted.
Test alternative explanations.
Challenge yourself to come up with two plausible, non-judgmental reasons for the person’s behavior before deciding how to respond.
Reflect on past false alarms.
Think of a time when your first impression turned out to be incomplete or wrong, and what you learned from it.
Reflection Questions
- When have my first judgments about a person been wrong, and what did I miss?
- What emotional reactions do I notice when I feel uncertain about someone new?
- How can I practice noticing assumptions without acting on them immediately?
- What would it feel like to give someone else, and myself, more time before deciding?
Personalization Tips
- At work, a coworker seems standoffish; instead of assuming they’re rude, consider they might be anxious in new groups.
- In class, a new student sits alone; you might assume they don’t want friends, but maybe they're just shy.
- At a party, someone ignores you; perhaps they’re overwhelmed, not disinterested.
How to Keep House While Drowning
Ready to Take Action?
Get the Mentorist app and turn insights like these into daily habits.