Short answer: pick Headway if you want to read and remember more: it has a larger library (1,700+ summaries), flashcards and challenges. Pick Mentorist if you want to act on what you read: one concrete step a day from a book and an AI mentor that remembers your goals and asks how it went. Mentorist is aimed especially at people who lead teams.
Disclosure: I'm the founder of Mentorist. Headway facts are from makeheadway.com and its App Store listing in November 2026.
Mentorist vs Headway at a glance
| Headway | Mentorist | |
|---|---|---|
| Core idea | Daily microlearning from book summaries | One action a day from a book, with an AI mentor |
| Library | 1,700+ summaries | 700+ books |
| Daily format | 15-minute text and audio summaries, daily insights | 3–5 minute insight (text or audio), "do this now" action, 2-minute fallback |
| Remembering | Spaced-repetition flashcards, streaks, challenges | Notes on insights; the mentor remembers your goals and commitments |
| AI | No AI coach described | Mentor chat grounded in the books |
| Free option | Trial (length not stated) | Daily free book, a few mentor messages; 7-day trial of the paid plans if eligible |
| Price (US App Store) | Premium items from $12.99 to $89.99 | with AI mentor $39.99/mo or $189/yr; without AI $19.99/mo or $97.99/yr |
| Languages | 11 app languages incl. Polish | English; Polish site, smaller Polish library, mentor in Polish |
| Platforms | iOS, iPad, Apple Watch, Android, web | iOS, Android, web |
Where Headway is stronger
A larger library, a daily habit loop with streaks and challenges, flashcards that help you retain ideas and vocabulary, more app languages, and more devices including the Apple Watch. Headway says its summaries are written by a team of people. It is also likely to cost less, depending on the offer you get.
Where Mentorist is different
Headway helps you remember an idea. Mentorist tries to get you to use it. Each insight ends with something to do today, sized so that a busy day still has a 2-minute version. When a real situation comes up, you can ask the mentor about it ("how do I tell a senior person their work isn't good enough?"); the answer draws on the books, and the mentor keeps track of what you said you would try and follows up. For a manager, that is closer to having a mentor than to reading a summary.
Who should choose which
- Headway: you enjoy reading summaries every day and want to retain more of them.
- Mentorist: you already know plenty of ideas and want help applying them, especially at work with a team.
Related: Best Headway alternatives · Mentorist vs Blinkist · Best apps for new managers